Register   Login
 Search   
My Resources  

CSU Equine Sciences
Discussion Forums  
New ThreadMy SettingsMy PostsSearchForum Home
  Topics  Horse Slaughter  Slaughter in th...
 Slaughter in the U.S.
 
 2/28/2008 4:20:29 PM
KBrim
14 posts


Slaughter in the U.S.
QuoteReply

Where do you sit on the issue of horse slaughter? Do you believe that horse slaughter should be maintained in the U.S.? Why or why not? 

Your opinions and comments are welcome. This is an opportunity for us to learn from one another and share our knowledge and experiences. Please refrain from abusive or offensive language, as any posts containing such items will be removed.

 3/3/2008 3:27:11 AM
Banker
13 posts


Re: Slaughter in the U.S.
QuoteReply
I sit in favor of horse slaughter, and I believe it should be maintained in the U.S.

I just flipped through a regional horse magazine, and couldn't help but be amazed at the number of stallions standing and the number of 'prospects' for sale. We have a plethora of breeders generating a multitude of horses that won't be ridden, usable, of use as companion animals or even cared for. Until this rampant reproduction is curbed, we have not other means of disposing of these horses. I certainly don't like it, but don't really see another way out.

I live next door to some alleged 'horse people'. They think they are so pretty, etc... and just keep having colts. They now have overgrazed their property so much that they are knocking down fence to get something in their belly. No one will buy the horses for "what they are worth", so they just get added to the starving pile.

These same people are against slaughter because they perceive it to be cruel. Uh, hello!?! Let's reward veterinarians for spaying and gelding horses. Our other choice is to start horse-pounds, and we know how well that has worked with dogs! I'll get off my soapbox now.

Thanks-
 3/9/2008 4:43:39 PM
debandterry
2 posts


Re: Slaughter in the U.S.
QuoteReply

I am opposed to horse slaughter.  Unfortunately, a lot of people that are opposed in principle believe there is no other option in practicality.  That is not true.  This is a problem well within our ability to solve without slaughter.  Start with breed registries limiting the number of foals that can be registered by a stallion each year.  And limit mares to one foal registered per year.  Statistics show that the 2 biggest breed contributors to slaughter are QH and TB.  The TB people are making efforts to change that.  What are the QH people doing?  Studies show there are 900,000 horse deaths each year, of which 100,000 are slaughtered, but 1.4 million foals are born.  Those numbers indicate that this "unwanted" horse problem does not have to be a crisis, nor resolved by slaughter.  Responsible breeding and ownership are the answer!  We don't have an "Unwanted Horse" problem.  The horses are a symptom of the problem - irresponsible people!   Over 90% of the horses slaughtered are healthy horses - not the old, tired, infirm ones like the pulbic in general believes.  And the old, tired, and infirm ones deserve our respect and compassion after serving their masters for years - humane euthanasia.  Another theory put forth by the proslaughter camp is that the slaughter in the U.S. is humane.  It is not.

 3/10/2008 3:51:14 AM
rick
2 posts


Re: Slaughter in the U.S.
QuoteReply

debandterry WOW limit mares to one foal registered per year.  This statement goes to show you how little most so called experts on the horse slaughter issue actually know about horses.  Debandterry you must of really done your research.  Debandterry look up in your idiots guide to raising horses and see how long a mares gestation period is.  People with actual knowledge of horses understand the need for horse slaughter.   

 3/11/2008 12:54:49 AM
debandterry
2 posts


Re: Slaughter in the U.S.
QuoteReply

Careful with the idiot language there Rick.  Science has come a long way, and it is now possible for a mares fertilized eggs to be implanted in a surrogate mare.  Some registries have already banned it.

  Topics  Horse Slaughter  Slaughter in th...
  Copyright 2007 by IMI Global
Terms Of Use   Privacy Statement